This issue of
Alcohol Alert examines the diagnosis and treatment of alcoholic liver
disease (ALD), a serious and potentially fatal consequence of drinking
alcohol. Another disorder, hepatitis C, also featured here, often is found
in patients with ALD.
ALD—FROM STEATOSIS TO
CIRRHOSIS
ALD includes three
conditions: fatty liver, alcoholic hepatitis, and cirrhosis. Heavy drinking
for as little as a few days can lead to “fatty” liver, or steatosis—the
earliest stage of alcoholic liver disease and the most common
alcohol–induced liver disorder. Steatosis is marked by an excessive buildup
of fat inside liver cells. This condition can be reversed, however, when
drinking stops.
Drinking heavily for
longer periods may lead to a more severe, and potentially fatal condition,
alcoholic hepatitis—an inflammation of the liver. Symptoms include nausea,
lack of appetite, vomiting, fever, abdominal pain and tenderness, jaundice,
and, sometimes, mental confusion. Scientists believe that if drinking
continues, in some patients this inflammation eventually leads to alcoholic
cirrhosis, in which healthy liver cells are replaced by scar tissue
(fibrosis), leaving the liver unable to perform its vital functions.
The presence of
alcoholic hepatitis is a red flag that cirrhosis may soon follow: Up to 70
percent of all alcoholic hepatitis patients eventually may go on to develop
cirrhosis (1). Patients with alcoholic hepatitis who stop drinking may have
a complete recovery from liver disease, or they still may develop cirrhosis.
Liver cirrhosis is a
major cause of death in the United States (2,3). In 2000, it was the 12th
leading cause of death. Cirrhosis mortality rates vary substantially among
age groups: They are very low among young people but increase considerably
in middle age. In fact, cirrhosis is the fourth leading cause of death in
people ages 45–54 (4).
Other factors besides
alcohol also may influence ALD development, including demographic and
biological factors such as ethnic and racial background, gender, age,
education, income, employment, and a family history of drinking problems
(5).
Women are at higher
risk than men for developing cirrhosis (6). This higher risk may be the
result of differences in the way alcohol is absorbed and broken down. When a
woman drinks, the alcohol in her bloodstream reaches a higher level than a
man’s even if both are drinking the same amount. The chemicals involved in
breaking down alcohol also differ between men and women. For example,
women’s stomachs may contain less of a key enzyme (alcohol dehydrogenase)
needed for the initial breakdown of alcohol. This means that a woman breaks
down alcohol at a slower rate, exposing her liver to higher blood alcohol
concentrations for longer periods of time (7)—a situation that is
potentially toxic to the liver. Differences in how a woman’s body breaks
down and removes alcohol also may be linked to how much and how often she
drinks, the fact that estrogen is present in her body, and even her liver
size (8).
DIAGNOSIS
Diagnosing ALD is a
challenge. A history of heavy alcohol use along with certain physical signs
and positive laboratory tests for liver disease are the best indicators of
disease. Alcohol dependence is not necessarily a prerequisite for ALD, and
ALD can be difficult to diagnose because patients often minimize or deny
their alcohol abuse. Even more confounding is the fact that physical exams
and lab findings may not specifically point to ALD (9).
Diagnosis typically
relies on laboratory tests of three liver enzymes: gamma–glutamyltransferase
(GGT), aspartate aminotransferase (AST), and alanine aminotransferase (ALT).
Liver disease is the most likely diagnosis if the AST level is more than
twice that of ALT (9), a ratio some studies have found in more than 80
percent of alcoholic liver disease patients. An elevated level of the liver
enzyme GGT is another gauge of heavy alcohol use and liver injury. Of the
three enzymes, GGT is the best indicator of excessive alcohol consumption,
but GGT is present in many organs and is increased by other drugs as well,
so high GGT levels do not necessarily mean the patient is abusing alcohol.
TREATMENT
Treatment strategies
for ALD include lifestyle changes to reduce alcohol consumption, cigarette
smoking, and obesity; nutritional therapy; pharmacological therapy; and
possibly liver transplantation (in case of cirrhosis).
Lifestyle Changes
—Abstinence from alcohol is vital to prevent further liver
injury, scarring, and possibly liver cancer; it appears to benefit patients
at each stage of the disease. Although only a few studies have looked
specifically at the effects of abstinence on the progression of ALD,
virtually every one has shown that abstaining from alcohol is beneficial
(10,11).
Many people who drink
alcohol also smoke cigarettes, and European studies have found scarring of
the liver occurs more rapidly in ALD patients who smoked (12,13). Obesity is
another factor associated with liver disease—specifically, the development
of fatty liver and nonalcoholic steatohepatitis, a disorder similar to
alcoholic hepatitis. Thus, stopping smoking and maintaining a healthy weight
are two more measures patients can take to reduce or prevent further liver
injury.
|
Treatment for Alcoholic Liver Disease |
- Lifestyle
modification (decreasing alcohol use, stopping smoking, losing
weight).
-
Appropriate nutritional, vitamin supplementation.
- Use of
pentoxifylline or prednisone for alcoholic hepatitis.
-
Complementary and alternative medicine (e.g., SAMe) for
cirrhosis.
-
Transplantation in selected abstinent patients with severe
disease.
|
Nutritional Treatment
Although alcoholic beverages contain calories, research
suggests that under certain conditions these calories do not have as much
value for the body as those derived from other nutrients (14). In addition,
many alcoholics suffer from malnutrition, which can lead to liver damage and
impaired liver function (15). Many drinkers take in less than the
recommended daily amount of carbohydrates, proteins, fats, vitamins (A, C,
and B, especially thiamine [B1]), and minerals (such as calcium and iron).
To prevent these deficiencies, clinicians should provide alcoholics with a
balanced diet. Dietary supplements may prevent or relieve some of alcohol’s
harmful effects. For example, brain damage resulting from a lack of vitamin
B1, which can lead to conditions such as Wernicke–Korsakoff syndrome, can be
reversed to some extent. Because vitamin B1 generally can be administered
safely, clinicians often recommend that all alcoholics undergoing treatment
receive 50 milligrams of thiamine per day (either by injection if the
patients are hospitalized or by mouth). Alcoholics also should receive
supplements of vitamins B2 (riboflavin) and B6 (pyridoxine) in dosages found
in standard multivitamins. Vitamin A, however, can be toxic when combined
with alcohol and should be given only to those alcoholics who have a
well–documented deficiency and who can stop or significantly reduce their
drinking (15).
In addition to dietary
supplements, alcoholics with moderate malnutrition might benefit from
treatment with anabolic steroids (16). These compounds, which are derived
from the male hormone testosterone, can be used in the short term to promote
overall body “buildup” and, therefore, may help the alcoholic better recover
from malnutrition.
Emerging Therapies
Studies using animals are helping researchers find other
dietary supplements that may help in the treatment of liver disease. For
example, eating certain healthy fats (called medium–chain triglycerides, or
MCTs) may help to reduce the buildup of harmful fats in the liver (17,18).
MCTs generally are available only in health food stores as a dietary
supplement.
Oxidative stress plays
a major role in the development of alcoholic liver disease. Oxidative stress
occurs when harmful oxygen molecules, or free radicals, form in the body.
These molecules are highly charged and very unstable. They cause cellular
changes in their effort to pair with the nearest available molecule,
injuring cells and modifying their function. Antioxidants can help prevent
this free radical damage.
An important
antioxidant, glutathione, or GSH, cannot be used as a supplement because
this substance cannot directly enter the cells threatened by oxidative
stress. However, researchers are using a precursor compound, the molecule
S–adenosylmethionine (SAMe), which can enter the cells and then break down
to form the helpful antioxidant. When SAMe was given to patients with
alcoholic cirrhosis in a clinical trial, they were significantly less likely
to die or require a liver transplant within the next 2 years, compared with
patients who had received an inactive substance (that is, a placebo) (19).
Moreover, the study detected virtually no harmful side effects of SAMe
treatment. Thus, this approach appears to hold promise for the treatment of
patients with ALD (20).
Pharmacological Therapy
No FDA–approved therapy exists for either alcoholic cirrhosis or alcoholic
hepatitis. However, several drugs have been used “off label,” including
pentoxifylline (PTX) and corticosteroids. PTX was shown to be effective in
patients with severe alcoholic hepatitis. Akriviadis and colleagues (21)
treated 49 patients with PTX and 52 patients with placebo (vitamin B12) for
4 weeks and found that PTX improved survival: 12 PTX patients died (24.5
percent), compared with 24 placebo patients (46 percent).
Although
corticosteroids are the most extensively studied form of therapy for
alcoholic hepatitis, their usefulness may be only short–term. Mathurin and
colleagues (22) reported significantly improved survival at 28 days (85
percent vs. 65 percent) in severely ill alcoholic hepatitis patients, but
this survival advantage did not extend much longer than a year. Most
investigators agree that if corticosteroids are used, they should be
reserved for patients with the most severe liver disease. In addition,
steroids have well–documented side effects, including increasing the risk of
infection, which already is substantial in patients with alcoholic hepatitis
(9).
TRANSPLANTATION
Liver transplantation
currently is the only definitive treatment for severe (end stage) liver
failure. A total of 41,734 liver transplants using
organs from cadavers were performed in the United States between 1992 and
2001 (23). Of these, 12.5 percent were performed in patients with ALD, and
5.8 percent were performed in patients with ALD and a concurrent infection
with the hepatitis C virus (HCV), making ALD the second most frequent reason
(after HCV infection alone) for transplantation (24).
ALD patients must
undergo a thorough evaluation to determine whether they are suitable
candidates for transplant. This screening addresses any coexisting medical
problems, such as heart damage, cancer, pancreatitis, and osteoporosis,
which might influence the outcome of the transplant. It includes a
psychological evaluation to identify those patients who are most likely to
remain abstinent and comply with the strict medical regimen that follows the
procedure (24).
For transplantation to
be successful in alcoholic patients it is essential that they remain
abstinent after the surgery and comply with a demanding medical regimen
(e.g., consistently take the necessary antirejection medications). Routinely
conducting psychiatric evaluations before patients are included on the list
of candidates for transplantation helps to identify those who may not be
able to meet these criteria (24).
Because of the
shortage of donated organs, transplantation to patients with alcoholic liver
disease remains controversial, mainly out of concern that the transplanted
liver could be “wasted” if a patient relapses to drinking and damages the
new liver as well. Yet the relapse rates in patients following transplant
are lower than in patients undergoing alcoholism treatment, and serious
relapses that adversely affect the transplanted liver or the patient are
uncommon. In contrast, patients who receive a transplant because of an
infection with hepatitis B or C viruses typically experience disease
recurrence and are more likely to lose the transplanted liver because of
recurrence of these infections (24).
Another concern is that patients with ALD will not be able to comply with
the antirejection medication regimen, but this has not been supported by
research. Liver rejection rates are similar for patients transplanted for
ALD and those transplanted for other types of liver disease, indicating
comparable rates of compliance with the antirejection medications. Finally,
it was believed that ALD patients would use more resources, thereby
incurring higher costs than non–ALD patients, but again this assumption has
not been corroborated by research evidence (25).
In contrast to these
negative assumptions on the use of liver transplants in ALD patients, many
clinicians contend that ALD is, in fact, an excellent reason for liver
transplantation. The overall improvement in patients with ALD after
transplant, including higher productivity and better quality of life,
supports considering these patients for liver transplants. Moreover, the
long–term costs of transplantation and subsequent management of the
alcoholic patient may well be lower than the costs of managing alcoholism
and ALD without transplantation (26).
SUMMARY
The liver is one of
the largest organs in the body. It performs many of the vital functions
necessary for maintaining good health. The liver is remarkably resilient in
responding to disease and infection and, in fact, under certain
circumstances, can even generate whole new sections of itself to replace
those that are diseased.
Alcohol is a toxin that is especially harmful to the liver, and alcoholic
liver disease—particularly cirrhosis—is one of the leading causes of
alcohol–related death. Not everyone who drinks heavily will develop ALD.
Other factors besides alcohol also influence development of the disease,
including demographic, biological, and environmental factors. Nevertheless,
stopping drinking can help to alleviate or even reverse ALD, especially in
the early stages of disease.
Treatment for ALD
includes making lifestyle changes, such as stopping or decreasing alcohol
use, stopping smoking, and maintaining a healthy weight. Health care
providers may prescribe medications, such as pentoxifylline or prednisone,
in cases of alcoholic hepatitis. And patients may want to seek nutritional
supplements or complementary and alternative medicine, such as SAMe for
cirrhosis. Severe ALD is best treated with transplantation in selected
abstinent patients.
REFERENCES
(1)
Bird, G.L., and Williams, R. Factors
determining cirrhosis in alcoholic liver disease. Molecular Aspects of
Medicine 10(2):97–105, 1988. (2) Yoon, Y.–H.; Yi, H.;
Grant, B.F.; et al. Surveillance Report No. 60: Liver Cirrhosis
Mortality in the United States, 1970–99. Washington, DC: National
Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism, 2002. (3) Minino, A.;
Arias, E.; Kochanek, K.D.; et al. Deaths: Final data for 2000.
National Vital Statistics Reports 50: 1–107, 2002. (4) Mann, R.E.;
Smart, R.G.; and Govoni, R. The epidemiology of alcoholic liver
disease. Alcohol Research & Health 27(3): 209–219, 2003.
(5) Jones–Webb, R. Drinking patterns and problems among
African–Americans: Recent findings. Alcohol Health & Research World
22(4): 260–264, 1998. (6) Tuyns, A.J., and Péquignot, G.
Greater risk of ascitic cirrhosis in females in relation to alcohol
consumption. International Journal of Epidemiology 13:53–57, 1984.
(7) Frezza, M.; Di Padova, C.; Pozzato, G.; et al. High
blood alcohol levels in women: The role of decreased gastric alcohol
dehydrogenase activity and first–pass metabolism. New England Journal of
Medicine 322:95–99, 1990. (8) Ramchandani, V.A.;
Bosron, W.F.; and Li, T.K. Research advances in ethanol metabolism.
Pathologie Biologie 49:676–682, 2001. (9) Marsano, L.S.;
Mendez, C.; Hill, D.; et al. Diagnosis and treatment of alcoholic
liver disease and its complications. Alcohol Research & Health
27(3):247–256, 2003. (10) Powell, W.J., Jr., and Klatskin,
G. Duration of survival in patients with Laennec’s cirrhosis. Influence of
alcohol withdrawal, and possible effects of recent changes in general
management of the disease. American Journal of Medicine
44(3):406–420, 1968. (11) Merkel, C.; Marchesini, G.;
Fabbri, A.; et al. The course of galactose elimination capacity in patients
with alcoholic cirrhosis: Possible use as a surrogate marker for death.
Hepatology 24(4): 820–823, 1996. (12) Klatsky, A.L.,
and Armstrong, M.A. Alcohol, smoking, coffee, and cirrhosis. American
Journal of Epidemiology 136(10):1248–1257, 1992. (13) Corrao,
G.; Lepore, A.R.; Torchio, P.; et al. The effect of drinking coffee
and smoking cigarettes on the risk of cirrhosis associated with alcohol
consumption. A case–control study. European Journal of Epidemiology
10(6):657–664, 1994. (14) Pirola, R.C., and Lieber, C.S.
The energy cost of the metabolism of drugs including ethanol.
Pharmacology 7:185–196, 1972. (15) Lieber, C.S.
Relationships between nutrition, alcohol use, and liver disease. Alcohol
Research & Health 27(3):220–231, 2003. (16) Mendenhall, C.;
Roselle, G.A.; Gartside, P.; et al. Relationship of protein calorie
malnutrition to alcoholic liver disease: A reexamination of data from two
Veterans Administration Cooperative Studies. Alcoholism: Clinical and
Experimental Research 19(3):635–641, 1995. (17) Nanji, A.A.;
Yang, E.K.; Fogt, F.; et al. Medium–chain triglycerides and vitamin
E reduce the severity of established experimental alcoholic liver disease.
Journal of Pharmacology and Experimental Therapeutics
277:1694–1700, 1996. (18) Nanji, A.A.; Jokelainen, K.;
Tipoe, G.L.; et al. Dietary saturated fatty acids reverse inflammatory and
fibrotic changes in rat liver despite continued ethanol administration.
Journal of Pharmacology and Experimental Therapeutics 299:638–644,
2001. (19) Mato, J.M.; Camara, J.; Fernandez de Paz, J.; et
al. S–adenosylmethionine in alcoholic liver cirrhosis: A randomized,
placebo–controlled, double–blind multicenter clinical trial. Journal of
Hepatology 30(6):1081–1089, 1999. (20) Lieber, C.S. S–adenosylmethionine
(SAMe): Its role in the treatment of liver disorders. American Journal
of Clinical Nutrition 76:1183S–1187S, 2002. (21) Akriviadis,
E.; Botla, R.; Briggs, W.; et al. Pentoxifylline improves
short–term survival in severe acute alcoholic hepatitis: A double–blind,
placebo–controlled trial. Gastroenterology 119(6):1637–1648, 2000.
(22) Mathurin, P.; Mendenhall, C.L.; Carithers, R.L., Jr.;
et al. Corticosteroids improve short–term survival in patients with severe
alcoholic hepatitis (AH): Individual data analysis of the last three
randomized placebo controlled double blind trials of corticosteroids in
severe AH. Journal of Hepatology 36(4):480–487, 2002. (23)
United Network for Organ Sharing (UNOS). Public data from UNOS/OPTN
scientific registry. Accessed December 2002. Available at
http://www.unos.org.
(24) Anantharaju, A., and Van Thiel, D.H. Liver transplantation for
alcoholic liver disease. Alcohol Research & Health 27(3):257–269,
2003. (25) Campbell, D.A., Jr., and Lucey, M.R. Liver
transplantation for alcoholic cirrhosis. In: Busuttil, R.W., and Klintmalm,
G.B., eds. Transplantation of the Liver, 1st ed. Philadelphia: W.B.
Saunders, 1996. pp. 145–150. (26) Keeffe, E.B.
Comorbidities of alcoholic liver disease that affect outcome of orthotopic
liver transplantation. Liver Transplantation and Surgery 3:251–257,
1997.
All
material contained in the Alcohol Alert is in the public domain